Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Writing Without Writing


This morning I woke up from a dream in which I was framing one of my papers for a class based on the writings of Jorge Luis Borges. I haven’t read Borges for about 15 years, yet for some reason his musings of labyrinths and spiraling towers of a library swept into my dream world and somehow collided with my thoughts on qualitative inquiry. This actually happens to me quite a bit but I’ve never taken the time to reflect on the importance of this part of my writing process.

One thing I have found when teaching writing is that everyone’s process is individual. But for some reason, whenever I pick up a book on writing the author outlines specific steps that are necessary for writing production. Ironically, these steps are very different depending on the book I pick up. Some advocate for topic selection, outlining, paragraph development, revising, and editing. For these writers the process is very linear. For some reason, I’ve never been able to work in this trajectory. Creating an outline before I’ve put any words on the page is like being given a mystery bag of ingredients and being told to make lasagna. There are all these bits and pieces with no idea of how they will connect or meld together.

Other authors suggest a consistent time of simply writing. Often this is referred to as “free writing” in which you keep writing for a set period of time. It doesn’t matter what subject I write about as long as I keep writing. From these “ramblings,” gems of topics emerge and begin to take shape that I can later nurture into more concrete musings or essays. I’ve enjoyed these unstructured sessions yet seem to lack the discipline to make them happen on a consistent basis. In a recent attempt to utilize this approach more consistently I joined a web site called 750words.com. It seemed like a great tool in that I write at least 750 words a day. These writings are logged and I can see my progress each day. I receive an email each day that I don’t meet my goal as an incentive. It doesn’t work! I wrote for 3 days and have been getting the emails each day since. I don’t know why I don’t unsubscribe...
 
This brings me to my current reflection on how my dream this morning, and many other mornings, fits into my personal writing process. For some reason, I tend to need a frame or metaphor to work from when writing. This is different than an outline in that it is more conceptual than concrete. It is a set of ideas and ways of thinking about a topic. Sometimes these metaphors are used in an explicit way as the framework for my writing in that I make them visible for my reader. Other times they just lurk in the background implicitly, guiding my ideas and thoughts into words on the paper.

Most importantly, my current reflection on this element of my process has enlightened me to the fact that this part of the process is almost always “off the page.” It happens in my dreams, in the car when I’m driving, when I’m walking, or even in the shower. I’m reminded of research that I have read in recent years about the importance of daydreaming. Scientists have found that the “resting brain” makes important long-distance connections that help us to make “creative connections between ideas” (Whitfield-Gabrieli & Gabrieli, 2010). Even while I’ve been engaged in writing this reflection, I’m cognizant of the fact that I’ve stopped numerous times to stare at the window, wall, or computer screen.

When I consider how this fits specifically into my academic and scholarly writing experience, I do know that I have learned to put words on a page soon after an “off-the-page” experience takes place. I have learned this the hard way when I have had these connective experiences and then lost them by not writing them down. In this way, I guess I’m learning the delicate dance between my on- and off-the-page experiences. I’m learning to find comfort in the idea that I am writing even when I’m not “writing.”

Reference

Whitfield-Gabrieli, S., & Gabrieli, J. (2010, January). Idle minds and what
they may say about intelligence. Scientific American. Retrieved from http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=idle-minds-intelligence.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Lima Bean


I recently clicked on a link someone posted on Facebook that shared Captain Beefheart's espoused "10 Commandments of Guitar-Playing." Low on the list I read this statement,
"Even a lima bean has to have a piece of wet paper around it to make it grow."

It has "bean" with me everyday since! (Sorry, I couldn't resist the pun!)

I guess, first of all, it reminded me of the 40+ Ziploc bags taped to a classroom window each Spring. Each day of the experiment I was privileged to watch the excited faces of five- and six-year-old children as they bounded into the classroom to see if their bean had sprouted. 

Of course we always had the “control” beans that were kept in the dark. I remember one student who was in tears because she felt sorry for the beans in the dark that didn’t get to sprout like hers. She was so distraught that we eventually had to let them out into the light!

Aside from this memory, which serves to remind me how much I miss teaching, I’ve also been considering this statement as a metaphor for my experience as a doctoral student in which I’m the bean. Fortunately, I’m not in the control group lying in the dark (although it feels like it at times). I’ve been wrapped up in the wet paper towel of study. It’s often sticky and it causes my outer shell of confidence and purpose to crack and peel. Yet, at times, I feel a sprout of success pop up. I can feel the warmth of the sunlight coming through the window and I catch a glimpse of the vine that will someday be mine. Until that day, I will be thankful for the wet paper towel and baggie that serve to germinate my growth. 


By the way, if you would like to sprout your own lima bean, click here or here.





Tuesday, February 15, 2011

“Fly or Get By”

While reading the book, “Language Stories & Literacy Lessons,”* I was struck by a section on risk-taking. These researchers found that 3- and 4-year-old children were more “aggressive language learners” as they boldly tested their hypotheses about language use (reading and writing)...essentially to “make literacy fly” not just “get by” (p. 139). The result is that they “get themselves into more trouble, and...are more successful than their older, wiser, and more cautious literate friends” (pp. 139-140).


We’ve all heard the motivating story of Thomas Edison and his numerous failed attempts at inventing the incandescent light bulb. He’s heralded for not giving up, for letting nothing stand in his way of success! He once said, “I am not discouraged, because every wrong attempt discarded is another step forward.”** We all applaud and echo, “Yes! Never give up, never surrender!” (Don’t you just love Galaxy Quest?) Yet, when it comes to our own lives, risk-taking is less applauded. Possibly we are deterred by the fact that no one writes of the courage and braveness of those in the pursuit who have not attained success. Imagine the reporter in Edison’s lab after his 122nd failed attempt. Would that journalist have proclaimed him as a genius?
As I think about this new adventure, my journey to a Ph.D., I don’t feel much different than those 3- and 4-year-olds or Thomas Edison when it comes to risk-taking. I’m immersed in newness! Newness of thought, newness of reading, newness of writing. At times I throw myself into writing or research and come out on the other side with not much more than scribbles on the paper. Yet, I choose to celebrate each scribbling! I seek out people to provide input on how I can improve because I know that with each scribbling, I’m that much closer to success!
*Harste, J. C., Woodward, V. A., & Burke, C. L. (1984). Language stories & literacy lessons.
Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.

Saturday, November 6, 2010

On the Eats - Delicata Squash Soup

Okay, so today's post is more related to another side of my journey...eating! Living alone + the relentless grind of school/work="I don't feel like cooking!" So I'm continually looking for healthy options that are quick and not too labor-intensive.

This past weekend I purchased some of my favorite squash, delicata,
with the plans to just cook them and eat them. Tonight I decided I wanted some soup and the delicata sounded perfectly yummy! I looked at a few recipes online and then decided to just go it on my own. The results were delicious and it was really easy to make.

Delicata Squash Soup
serves 2

Ingredients:
1 delicata squash, cooked and flesh scooped out*
2 T butter
1/2 cup diced onion
1 T "Gourmet Garden Ginger Spice Blend"
1/4 t. ground cumin
1/2 t. garlic powder
1 c. chicken stock (or vegetable stock)
1/4 cup milk (can use cream if you want it thicker)
Dash of paprika

Directions:
1. Saute onion and ginger spice blend in butter until onions are translucent.
2. Put sauteed onion mixture and remaining ingredients (except for paprika) in a food processor and puree until smooth.

3. If soup has cooled, reheat on the stove or microwave.
4. Pour into bowls and sprinkle with paprika

*Use your favorite method to cook the squash. I cut the squash in half, scooped out the seeds, placed the two halves flesh-side down in a lidded casserole dish with a small amount of water in the bottom and bake at 350 degrees for 45 min.

Friday, October 15, 2010

From Waterskiing to Research

I begin today’s post by telling a story. When I was a teenager I learned to waterski. Now, I caution you against thinking this led to a level of proficiency of a professional waterskier. It was more along the lines of Twiggy, the waterskiing squirrel!

I did eventually get up (on two skis) and manage to enjoy it. However, the process from going from bobbing up and down in the water, life-vest hunched up over my ears, clinging for dear life to the rope handle, to feeling the exhilaration of the wind and the spray on my face was arduous at best! The worst part was all the “help” coming from well-meaning teachers in the boat--”keep your skis together...lean back...don’t lean back too far...don’t stand up too early...sit back on your skis, point your toes” and one of my personal favorites, “let the rope do the work”...yeah, right! It was all “good” advice! But when clinging to a rope attached to a boat that soon will propel me forward at speeds of up to 20 to 30 mph, executing such instructions was a challenge, to say the least.
I might have waterskied about three or four times after that. Each time it got a bit easier and I didn’t have to think about the “exactness” of each and every muscle and movement of my body in relation to the skis, rope, and boat. Well, here I am again, bobbing up and down, life-vest hunched up over my ears, clinging to the handle. Only this time I’m treading the lake of research. They’re all there...those “teachers” yelling from the boat. My teachers, some literal, some through books (I’m currently reading 4 books on research), all want me to succeed. They have lots of advice that I am thankful for. However, I can’t help but feel a little frustrated as I am bombarded with instructions of how to do this thing...research. Here are just a few instructions I’m hearing:
Know that uncertainty and anxiety are natural and inevitable... (Booth et al., 1995)
Get control over your topic...
Break the task into manageable steps...
Recognize the struggle for what it is...
Plan your search...
Take full notes...
Know when to quote, paraphrase, summarize...
Get the context right...
Just to name a few!
At this point, the only part of performing research that I am somewhat comfortable doing is the literature review. Even that I’m worried about in finding the time to conduct it with all the other reading and work I need to get completed. All other portions...identifying, or rather articulating the research problem...creating a purpose statement...laying down the research questions...finding research participants...approaching the participants...creating and using an interview guide...conducting an interview...conducting a thorough observation...writing a “thick” description of the interviews and/or observations...positioning myself as the researcher...identifying my subjectivities...writing about my subjectivities in an academic manner...analyzing data...reporting data...these are all areas that I’m petrified of!
In reading “The Craft of Research” I literally burst in laughter at the following “Quick Tip”:
“As you get deeper into your project, you may experience a moment when everything seems to run together into a hopeless muddle...The bad news is that you can’t avoid all such moments; the good news is that eventually they pass” (p. 101).
I’m waiting for this one to pass....
Reference
Booth, W.C., Colomb, G.G., Williams, J.M. (1995) The craft of research. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Epiphany!

Epiphany!
I hear someone say, “I had an epiphany!” and I just role my eyes. There are some words in our English language that are overworked and misused and I’ve always felt this is one of them. I put it right in the same category as “epic” which is used to refer to just about any idea or event that someone likes these days. Just Googling the word “epiphany” brings a 7,570,000 hits that range from wine-making (Epiphany, 2010b) to music (Epiphany, 2010c) not to mention the 514,000 hits that come from Googling books with that word!
So, it is with fear and trepidation that I now add my voice to the throng exclaiming, “I had an epiphany!” Yet I find that it is the only word to describe yesterday’s experience. This sends me searching for context...
Merriam Webster’s web site defines “epiphany” as
(from Greek epiphaneia, “manifestation”), festival celebrated on January 6; it is one of the three principal and oldest festival days of the Christian Church (including Easter and Christmas). It commemorates the first manifestation of Jesus Christ to the Gentiles, represented by the Magi, and the manifestation of his divinity, as it occurred at his Baptism in the Jordan River and at his first miracle at Cana in Gallilee (Epiphany, 2010a).
Now, I’m not saying that what I experienced yesterday is on the same level as the proclamation of the Diety of Jesus Christ! Maybe Dictionary.com’s second definition relates more closely to what I experienced:
a sudden, intuitive perception of or insight into the reality or essential meaning of something, usually initiated by some simple, homely, or commonplace occurrence or experience (Epiphany, 2010d).
Yeah...that is definitely closer. And “what,” you may ask, “was this sudden perception or insight into the essential meaning of something?”  As you might remember from my last post, my research interests kept broadening instead of narrowing. While this may seem like a trivial matter, it’s extremely frustrating when I have needed to create a small study. I found myself designing something that I really wasn’t that passionate about simply due to the time table of an assignment. All the advice I had been getting told me to tailor each assignment toward my research interest and since I hadn’t even come close to an area of study it was becoming increasingly more difficult.
Then, initiated by a simple, commonplace occurrence of a conversation, it “suddenly” came to me...a small study that is directly related to a research direction I am passionate about! I felt like telling the world! And although it wasn’t a spiritual revelation, it was an experience that I will never forget...that day...that time...that place where I found my niche in the research world!
References
Epiphany (2010a). In Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved September 29, 2010, from
     Encyclopædia Britannica Online:
Epiphany by Christette Michele (2010b). Retrieved September 29, 2010, from 
Epiphany (2010c). Retrieved September 29, 2010, from Amazon.com 
Epiphany (2010d). Retrieved September 29, 2010, from Dictionary.com 

Monday, September 20, 2010

Another Idea?!

So, I was told that my research interests would narrow as I got into the program. I had in mind the fundraising coin collector apparatus you often see in McDonalds. You know...the big yellow "funnel" that you start a coin rolling and with centripetal force it eventually lands in it's home? Well, something's wrong! My funnel is upside-down. My research "coin" is defying the laws of nature--gravity and centripetal force! Instead of spinning to it's home inside my brain, the coin keeps gaining speed upward and outward--gathering more and more ideas.

The saying goes, "If you can't beat 'em, join 'em." That's what I've decided to do. I just keep writing the ideas down and hope that someday my funnel will invert--it will have to for my dissertation. In this spirit...if you've had a plaguing question about literacy of any kind...let me know. I'll add it to my pile and if I ever pursue it and it gets published...you'll get credit for the idea!